| Year | Location | 1st Place | 2nd Place | Semifinalists |
| 2007 | Sarasota, FL | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Johnny Bravo Boulder, CO | GOAT Jam |
| 2006 | Sarasota, FL | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Furious George Vancouver, BC | Chain Lightning Johnny Bravo |
| 2005 | Sarasota, FL | Furious George Vancouver, BC | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Death or Glory Jam |
| 2004 | Sarasota, FL | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Jam San Francisco, CA | Furious George Pike |
| 2003 | Sarasota, FL | Furious George Vancouver, BC | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Jam Ring of Fire |
| 2002 | Sarasota, FL | Furious George Vancouver, BC | Ring of Fire Raleigh, NC | Death or Glory Sockeye |
| 2001 | Sarasota, FL | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Jam San Francisco, CA | Death or Glory Furious George |
| 2000 | Sarasota, FL | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Furious George Vancouver, BC | Death or Glory Jam |
| 1999 | San Diego, CA | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Furious George Sub Zero |
| 1998 | Sarasota, FL | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Ring of Fire WSL Allstars |
| 1997 | Sarasota, FL | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Chicago Z Ring of Fire |
| 1996 | Plano, TX | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Chicago Z Nice Guys |
| 1995 | Birmingham, AL | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Sockeye Seattle, WA | Cojones Double Happiness |
| 1994 | Lexington, KY | Death or Glory Boston, MA | Double Happiness San Francisco, CA | Chesapeake Cojones |
| 1993 | Selma, TX | New York New York, NY | Double Happiness San Francisco, CA | Big Brother Rhino Slam |
| 1992 | San Diego, CA | New York New York, NY | Commonwealth Boston, MA | Rhino Slam Windy City |
| 1991 | Sanford, FL | New York New York, NY | Big Brother Boston, MA | Iguanas Tsunami |
| 1990 | Palm Beach, FL | New York New York, NY | Iguanas Southern California | Titanic Windy City |
| 1989 | Washington, DC | New York New York, NY | Tsunami San Francisco, CA | Titanic Iguanas |
| 1988 | San Diego, CA | Tsunami San Francisco, CA | Titanic Boston, MA | New York Windy City |
| 1987 | Miami, FL | New York New York, NY | Windy City Chicago, IL | Titanic Tunas |
| 1986 | Houston, TX | Windy City Chicago, IL | Flying Circus San Francisco, CA | Kaboom Titanic |
| 1985 | Washington, DC | Flying Circus San Francisco, CA | Kaboom New York, NY | Windy City Tunas |
| 1984 | Santa Barbara, CA | Tunas St. Louis, MO | Flying Circus San Francisco, CA | Condors Windy City |
| 1983 | New Orleans, LA | Windy City Chicago, IL | Spinoffs San Diego, CA | Condors Sky Pilots |
| 1982 | Austin, TX | Rude Boys Boston, MA | Tunas St. Louis, MO | The Gang Hostages |
| 1981 | Austin, TX | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | Knights of Nee New Jersey | 3. Sky Pilots 4. Hostages |
| 1980 | Atlanta, GA | Glassboro Glassboro, NJ | Aerodisc Boston, MA | 3. Michigan State 4. Condors |
| 1979 | State College, PA | Glassboro Glassboro, NJ | Condors Santa Barbara, CA | 3. Michigan State 4. Orlando |